A Personal Message from George Soros
Why We Must Not Re-elect President Bush
Prepared text of speech delivered at the National Press Club, Washington,
DC, September 28, 2004
This is the most important election of my lifetime. I have never been
heavily involved in partisan politics but these are not normal times.
President Bush is endangering our safety, hurting our vital interests and
undermining American values. That is why I am sending you this message. I
have been demonized by the Bush campaign but I hope you will give me a
hearing.
President Bush ran on the platform of a "humble" foreign policy in 2000. If
we re-elect him now, we endorse the Bush doctrine of preemptive action and
the invasion of Iraq, and we will have to live with the consequences. As I
shall try to show, we are facing a vicious circle of escalating violence
with no end in sight. But if we repudiate the Bush policies at the polls, we
shall have a better chance to regain the respect and support of the world
and to break the vicious circle.
When George W. Bush was elected president, and particularly after September
11, I saw that the values and principles of open society needed to be
defended at home. September 11 led to a suspension of the critical process
so essential to a democracy - a full and fair discussion of the issues.
President Bush silenced all criticism by calling it unpatriotic. When he
said that "either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists," I heard
alarm bells ringing. I am afraid that he is leading us in a very dangerous
direction. We are losing the values that have made America great.
The destruction of the twin towers of the World Trade Center was such a
horrendous event that it required a strong response. But the President
committed a fundamental error in thinking: the fact that the terrorists are
manifestly evil does not make whatever counter-actions we take automatically
good. What we do to combat terrorism may also be wrong. Recognizing that we
may be wrong is the foundation of an open society. President Bush admits no
doubt and does not base his decisions on a careful weighing of reality. For
18 months after 9/11 he managed to suppress all dissent. That is how he
could lead the nation so far in the wrong direction.
President Bush inadvertently played right into the hands of bin Laden. The
invasion of Afghanistan was justified: that was where bin Laden lived and al
Qaeda had its training camps. The invasion of Iraq was not similarly
justified. It was President Bush's unintended gift to bin Laden.
War and occupation create innocent victims. We count the body bags of
American soldiers; there have been more than 1000 in Iraq. The rest of the
world also looks at the Iraqis who get killed daily. There have been 20
times more.
I realize that what I am saying is bound to be unpopular. We are in the grip
of a collective misconception induced by the trauma of 9/11, and fostered by
the Bush administration. No politician could say it and hope to get elected.
How could President Bush convince people that he is good for our security,
better than John Kerry? By building on the fears generated by the collapse
of the twin towers and fostering a sense of danger. At a time of peril,
people rally around the flag and President Bush has exploited this. His
campaign is based on the assumption that people do not really care about the
truth and they will believe practically anything if it is repeated often
enough, particularly by a President at a time of war. There must be
something wrong with us if we fall for it. For instance, some 40% of the
people still believe that Saddam Hussein was connected with 9/11 - although
it is now definitely established by the 9/11 Commission, set up by the
President and chaired by a Republican, that there was no connection. I want
to shout from the roof tops: "Wake up America. Don't you realize that we are
being misled?"
NOTE: I edited this for brevity but invite you to read the speech in its entirety at www.georgesoros.com. It's an entirely good use of your time and one that will open your eyes.